How-To Guide
Blotato vs Planoly: which one should plan and publish your Instagram calendar?
Planoly plans the grid, Blotato publishes what an agent writes, and Superdirector runs an account at $199. Where each fits, from pages read November 15, 2026.
By the Superdirector editorial team. Every fact in this article was read from the cited pages on November 15, 2026; where a vendor's pages or third-party tables disagree, both readings are reported and neither is resolved.
At a glance
Blotato vs Planoly: which one should plan and publish your Instagram calendar?
Planoly is the planner of the pair. You see the Instagram grid, rearrange it, and schedule or take a reminder, and an agent can draft and schedule through Planoly's connector. Blotato is not a planner: it is the hosted API and MCP server your own agent publishes through, on nine platforms, and nothing on the Blotato pages read here documents a grid preview or a week of drafts written for you. Superdirector Growth is the third answer, a run account at $199 a month for one AI-run operated account that posts eligible Instagram carousels and single X posts once you turn posting on for the account. Choose Planoly if you want to keep and see the calendar, Blotato if your agent already writes and only needs the publish surface, and Superdirector if you want the calendar produced for you.
- Planoly: a visual grid, eight channels in one social set, auto-post where a platform allows it, a reminder where it does not, and a free mobile plan at 10 uploads a month.
- Blotato: 35 MCP tools, 9 platforms, analytics on 8, comments and DMs on Instagram and Facebook only, and no free plan.
- Superdirector: $29 Starter drafts inside Claude or ChatGPT; $199 Growth runs one AI-run operated account (the pricing page lists two account slots) and adds account-level posting to Instagram and X after one warning.
- The plan prices count different units (social sets, connected accounts, accounts), so compare the bill at your own count, not the entry line.
Uploads, the grid preview and the branch between auto-post and reminder, as Planoly's own pages describe them. Original diagram drawn from planoly.com and planoly.com/pricing, read November 15, 2026.
Make it work for your brand
Find it. Remake it. Post it. Superdirector turns the viral formats in your niche into your brand's carousels, X posts and video scripts, and keeps the calendar full.
The decision: who keeps the calendar
The pair looks like a tool comparison, but the buyer is choosing a job. Planoly is a visual planner: you see the Instagram feed, move posts until it looks right, and then publish on a schedule or take a reminder. Blotato is publishing infrastructure: your own agent writes the post, and Blotato's API and MCP server put it on nine platforms and read back what happened. One keeps the calendar visible; the other assumes the calendar is already made.
There is a third shape in the same decision. Superdirector Growth is a run account: it produces the calendar for an account and posts eligible Instagram carousels and single X text posts by itself once posting is turned on. It is not a grid you arrange. If the question is who does the planning, the honest answer is you in Planoly, your agent in Blotato, or the tool in Superdirector.
| Your week | Who builds it | Who publishes | What stays yours |
|---|---|---|---|
| You want to see the grid first | You, in Planoly | Planoly auto-posts where the platform allows it, otherwise it reminds you | The weekly look and the final yes |
| Your agent already writes the posts | Your agent | Blotato, through its API or MCP server | The approval step, which you add in the agent |
| You want the account run | Superdirector Growth | Growth posts eligible Instagram carousels and single X text posts after the account switch | Turning posting on once, and deciding what posts and what gets paid |
What Planoly actually is
Planoly calls itself the social media planner that goes way beyond scheduling. The feature that matters here is the grid: Planoly previews the Instagram feed and lets you rearrange posts until the feed feels right. It also says it auto-posts when a platform allows it and sends a reminder when native tools are the better choice, which is a narrower promise than every network posting by itself.
Its pricing is built on the social set. One set links one account on each of eight named channels: Instagram, Facebook, X, Pinterest, LinkedIn, YouTube, Threads and TikTok. Starter includes one user and one social set, extra users cost $5 a month on Growth and $3 on Pro, and extra sets cost $10 on Growth and $8 on Pro. The page says plans start at $14 a month and that annual billing saves up to 15%, and the free plan runs on the mobile app with 10 uploads a month.
The agent surface is real but younger than the planner. Planoly's connector page says Claude can now publish to all of your socials with Planoly, lists eight networks, connects through an OAuth login that never shows the assistant a password, and says the assistant gets a heads-up before anything publishes, posts or deletes. MCP access needs a paid ChatGPT plan on that app. Blotato's comparison counts 22 Planoly tools and says none of them handles comments, DMs or automation. That count is the competitor's, not Planoly's own list, and the page read here does not publish a tool count.
Third-party pages disagree about the reach. One card says Planoly supports seven networks and that only Blotato publishes to X and Bluesky; another lists Planoly at eight networks including X; Planoly's own page says auto-posting depends on the platform and otherwise becomes a reminder. If X matters, read the reminder rule before counting it as an auto-post channel.
What Blotato actually is
Blotato describes itself as agent infrastructure for social media marketing. It is a hosted REST API and a hosted MCP server with 35 named tools for agents, and it schedules posts on nine platforms. Its own capability sheet is unusually plain about the edges: analytics cover eight platforms with LinkedIn the one exclusion, comments and DMs work on Instagram and Facebook only, and the company enforces posting caps stricter than the platforms themselves, including 50 Instagram posts per 24 hours.
The commercial shape follows the API. Starter is $29 a month for 20 social accounts, Creator is $97 and Agency is $499, and every paid plan includes the API and MCP with no separate tier. There is no free plan. The seven-day trial covers the web app but not the API or MCP, and generating an API key ends the trial right away and starts the paid subscription. Yearly billing charges for ten months and gives twelve.
What the tool does not do is plan. Nothing on the Blotato pages read here documents a grid preview or a week of drafts written for the buyer. The work it replaces is publishing and engagement, not the editorial calendar. On approval, Blotato's comparison says either connector lets Claude require approval on each tool that publishes, so the gate is a client setting in the agent. A third-party comparison states the same limit more bluntly: no drafts, review or approval before an agent's post goes out.
| Question | Planoly | Blotato |
|---|---|---|
| Visual grid preview | Yes, its grid planner | Not documented on the pages read here |
| Networks it says it publishes to | 8 named on its connector page, with auto-post only where a platform allows | 9 platforms |
| Agent tools | Connector page lists 8 networks; Blotato's comparison counts 22 tools | 35 MCP tools |
| Comments and DMs | Not in the MCP surface, per Blotato's comparison | Instagram and Facebook only |
| Free option | Free mobile plan, 10 uploads a month | No free plan, 7-day trial |
| What the bill counts | Social sets and users | Connected accounts, flat tiers |
Where the two tools stop, and what a run account adds
Neither tool answers the offer label in this cluster: a $199 buyer job where the account is run for the buyer. Superdirector splits its plans on that line. Starter at $29 a month covers live social data, ideas, scripts and downloads inside Claude or ChatGPT. Growth at $199 a month adds scheduled research, routines and supported Instagram and X publishing for one AI-run operated account, and charges $99 a month for each extra account slot.
Posting is account-level, not post-level. The pricing page says posting starts only when the buyer turns it on for an account, after one warning that names the account, the public effect and the cost. On Growth, Superdirector then publishes eligible Instagram carousels and single X text posts by itself. The buyer still decides what posts, what changes and what gets paid. A buyer who needs a named approver on every post is asking for a review workflow that Superdirector does not sell.
The MCP side is for drafting and operations, not publishing. The docs say approval covers all current and future Canvases the account owns, each task still names one Canvas and hidden context is excluded, and scheduled prompts run as the same paid Agent turn as the web app. The tool catalog read here lists Canvas, setup, sourcing, media and scheduling tools; it does not list a publish-to-Instagram tool. Credits cover AI work and are not a count of finished videos, and the roughly $199 per autonomous account is an estimate of running costs, not a plan price.
What each costs at the counts buyers run
The table below uses only printed plan marks, read November 15, 2026. The units are different, which is why the entry price is the wrong comparison.
| Surface | Entry | Middle | Top |
|---|---|---|---|
| Planoly | Starter: plans start at $14 a month, one user and one social set | Growth: $24 annual mark, two sets and two users; extra sets $10, extra users $5 | Pro: $47 annual mark, six sets and six users; extra sets $8, extra users $3 |
| Blotato | Starter $29 a month: 20 accounts, API and MCP | Creator $97: 40 accounts | Agency $499: 100 accounts |
| Superdirector | Starter $29 a month: drafting and downloads, no posting | Growth $199: one AI-run operated account, Instagram and X posting | Extra accounts $99 each a month |
Planoly's own page says plans start at $14 a month, and a third-party table prints $14, $24 and $47 for Starter, Growth and Pro. Blotato's comparison reads the same plans differently: Starter $16 a month or $14 billed yearly, Growth $28, and Pro $55, with the annual marks at Starter $14, Growth $24 and Pro $47. No checkout page read here settles which figure applies to a new monthly buyer, so check the checkout before choosing. Blotato's own tiers do not conflict across the pages read here: $29, $97 and $499.
Trial rules change the first month more than the plan price does. Every paid Planoly plan includes a 14-day trial, and the free mobile plan caps at 10 uploads a month. Blotato has no free plan; its seven-day trial excludes the API and MCP, and an API key ends the trial and starts billing. Superdirector's Starter has a seven-day trial with a card, and Growth has no trial and bills at checkout.
Two caps belong in the same decision. Planoly's free plan is a ten-upload tester, not a working calendar. Blotato's 50 Instagram posts per 24 hours is a ceiling its own page calls stricter than the platforms'. Neither reads as a hidden cost; both change what a busy week can do.
The cheapest rung counts something different from the others, so the entry price is not the comparison. Original diagram drawn from the plan marks printed on planoly.com/pricing, blotato.com/pricing and superdirector.app/pricing, read November 15, 2026.
What the pages read here leave open
Six questions stay open. Draft quality is one: no page shows the same brief planned in both tools, so the pages establish what ships, not which week reads better. Exact volume is another: Planoly prices social sets and users, Blotato prices accounts, and Superdirector prices accounts plus a plan, and none gives a worked total at five brands or forty accounts.
The sources also disagree on reach and price. Planoly's own page says auto-post depends on the platform and otherwise becomes a reminder; a third-party card says it supports seven networks and that only Blotato publishes to X and Bluesky; another lists eight networks including X. Planoly's page says plans start at $14 a month, Blotato's comparison prints $16/$28/$55 monthly against $14/$24/$47 yearly, and one third-party table prints $14/$24/$47 as the plan line. Planoly's connector says the assistant acts only inside the connected workspace, while Blotato's comparison quotes Planoly's setup guide saying the token reaches every workspace the member belongs to.
Two absences are worth naming because a buyer may need them. Planoly's own tool list was not read here; the 22-tool count comes from Blotato's comparison. Blotato's help-centre tool reference was not read either, so the 35-tool count rests on its capability sheet and comparison page. What would settle the page: a dated checkout at the buyer's own count, Planoly's tool list, and one Blotato tool-reference read on a single date.